Bernstein and Grazian had a falling out, so they folded their law practice. Grazian started his own firm, and took some cases with him from the firm he had with Bernstein. The two lawyers fought over how much each should be paid for those files. Bernstein sued Grazian, who countersued…
Articles Posted in Appellate Jurisdiction
Notice Of Appeal Fails To Confer Appellate Jurisdiction In Legal Malpractice Case
The beneficiaries of the Victoria R. Fitch Trust sued McDermott Will and Emery, the law firm that drafted Victoria’s estate plan, and Dietrich and Dietrich, the accounting firm that advised Victoria. The beneficiaries alleged a variety of legal claims for mishandling the estate plan. The first count of the Complaint…
Grandparents’ Appeal Of Dismissal Of Adoption Petition And Severance Order Lacks Jurisdiction. Appeal From Order Striking Response To Foster Parents’ Adoption Petition Allowed
After SG’s parents lost their parental rights, the Hixsons (grandparents) petitioned to adopt the child. Five days later, in a separate case, the Bakers (foster parents) also petitioned to adopt SG. The Bakers also asked the trial court to consolidate the two cases. Over objection by the Hixsons, the cases…
“Sellers Exception” Dismissal In Airplane Crash Product Liability Case Not Final And Appealable
Illinois law allows the seller of a product to get out of a product liability lawsuit after identifying the manufacturer of the product. But even if the dismissal is with prejudice, the dismissal order is not final and immediately appealable. The First District Illinois Appellate Court recently said it did…
Incorrectly Coded Notice Of Appeal Sufficient To Give Federal Appellate Court Jurisdiction
Summary judgment was entered against Scot Vince in his civil rights action against Rock County, Wisconsin. Using the court’s mandatory electronic filing system, Vince’s lawyer filed a notice of appeal on the last day allowed by the rule. The system requires an event code for each document filed. Vince’s lawyer…
Dismissal For Want Of Prosecution Appealable After Time For Refiling Expires
The First District Illinois Appellate Court recently stated the rule for when a dismissal for want of prosecution becomes final and appealable. Our supreme court has recognized that if a plaintiff’s action is dismissed for want of prosecution (DWP), the plaintiff has the option, under section 13-217 of the Code…
Voidness Of Judgment Considered Despite Late Appeal
American Access Casualty Company insured Aaron Hersey. GEICO won a negligence case against Hersey. Trying to satisfy its judgment, GEICO brought a supplemental proceeding to discover the assets of American Access Casualty Company. The trial court entered a judgment for GEICO against AACC for the amount GEICO won against Hersey.…
Jurisdiction Okay Despite Candidate’s Appeal Under Wrong Rule
Mary Ann Aiello passed away with more than 29 months left in her term on the Winnebago, Illinois County Board. Theodore Biondo was appointed to fill the vacancy. By the time Biondo’s appointment went through there was less than 28 months left in Aiello’s term. Under the Illinois Election Code,…
No Appellate Jurisdiction Over Trustee’s Appeal Filed Before Final Distribution Of Assets
After Eleanor Miller died, Melodee Miller-Hanson became the successor trustee of Eleanor’s trust. Melodee got into a dispute with the other beneficiaries of the trust, and they ended up suing each other. The beneficiaries wanted Melodee removed as trustee; Melodee wanted the beneficiaries disinherited. Melodee’s counterclaim was dismissed. And with…
Notice Of Appeal More Than 30 Days After 304(a) Finding Still Vests Appellate Jurisdiction
This insurance coverage case has a unique twist on when an interlocutory order under Illinois Supreme Court Rule 304(a) may be appealed. John J. Rickhoff Sheet Metal Co. filed a third-party complaint against Meridian Mutual Insurance Co and the Horton Group, Inc. Meridian and Horton asked the trial court to…